Defense Granted Subpoena Request in Cold Case Murder Trial

Be the reason your community stays informed—give to local journalism now! DECORAH — The defense team for James David Bachmurski, a Winneshiek County man currently facing charges of second-degree murder in the 2017 disappearance of 15-year-old Jade Marie Colvin, has been granted its request to subpoena evidence from the Ames Police Department. This subpoena is the latest as his defense continues to develop their case. Last week, the court issued the order in response to the defense's application under Iowa Rule of Criminal Procedure 2.15(3), which permits subpoenas for evidence when a proper showing is made. The evidence in question contains materials related to the "alleged victim's prior history of runaway behavior and specific tangible items of evidence regarding her methods and plans." This evidence could include documentation, 'tangible items' and potentially video or audio footage referenced in the case discovery materials but not directly given to the defense. Bachmurski's jury trial is set for March 19 of this year. Expert Perspective on 'Runaways'The focus on Colvin's purported history as a runaway contributes to broader concerns about how cases involving missing children are initially categorized and investigated. Experts, such as those at the Amber Alert's "Amber Advocate," emphasize that the label of "runaway" can lead to a critical delay in investigative efforts, potentially overlooking signs that a child may have been lured away or abducted. This label can also take focus away from perpetrators and instead project speculation onto their young victims. In Jade Colvin's case, her mother initially reported her missing in 2017. It was not until 2024 that Bachmurski was charged with her murder, although it is still unclear if this delay is related to the evidence that his legal team has subpoenaed. Elevate your inbox with the DecorahNews.com newsletter! Receive free thought-provoking articles, actionable advice and inspiring stories every week.